If I make a turtle soup joke, will you make a vore joke?

The most likely murderer is Her. While Robbydude and Kaban both had the chances, they were minuscule, and not observed. Meanwhile, no one witnessed Her actually jump down or do anything except go upstairs. No witnesses to validate means they're the best target.

Well, lets tally these up...

Oh! It's a TIE!
What? How is that possible? Well, it's easy!
HER is the ULTIMATE TACTICIAN [SHENANIGANS]

ULTIMATE TACTICIAN: Show

+If someone attempts to kill you, but fails, you learn who it was.
+You will be immune to repeat attempts from that player, unless that is the only attempt or they force a kill.
+Execution polls will automatically have one vote removed from all totals against you.
-If this removed vote changes the outcome, this role WILL be revealed.

+You have a second vote, which will be shown by TOM.

So, I guess I'll flip a coin.

...HER. Well, HER is INNOCENT, so.

TOM stabs HER in the chest with a SCOPED KNIFE. Thrice.


Eh, I'm too lazy to write fancy executions. Onto the next one...