Since yesterday, I've felt that something is...amiss. Much like the Traveller, I'm less certain now about things I once thought I knew.
At journey's end, the Traveller began to question whether the tale of the Black Scribe passed down through their culture was fact or fiction. Did the scribe really exist, or were they merely a cautionary tale? Perhaps the story was fabricated to offer an explanation for certain forces that govern our world, like faith and the occult. I'm no more qualified to answer the question than they were, but I do know that the Codex is real, as is the masked evildoer trying to lay claim to it.
But who are they really? Are they truly an ancient and enigmatic evil made manifest?
Traveller's musings aside, there are a couple other pieces of evidence sowing seeds of doubt in my mind. Mr. Sinclair himself seemed to doubt whether one person was solely responsible for the 2008 murders, and it seems that those "murders" may have been elaborate suicides in the end. And then, there's Mr. Columbo's memo...
"Much like collective faith is known to manifest and empower “deities” with the influx of Liturgic Esotera, an influx of Occultic Esotera carries the risk of potentially manifesting entities referred to in common vernacular as “demons”
"Particularly powerful Occultic artifacts may develop their own manifestation spontaneously to facilitate the gathering of Esotera."
Is it possible that the true identity of the mastermind isn't the Black Scribe, but rather...
a manifestation born of the Codex itself? A "demon" of sorts, created by the Codex to serve as its proxy and free it from its subterranean gaol. Based on the reports from 2008 and the latest IRC chat log, we can also posit that the tome is still radiating energies that affect people in the vicinity - whether to drive them to suicide, or to murder. It's feeding itself.
The BPI's tests utilizing the Codex as a power source may have caused it to reawaken. Thus, it summoned the "mastermind" once more after their defeat 20 years past, to begin the killing game and work toward the tome's release. Perhaps that may also be why so many seemingly well-adjusted people fell so quickly to the temptation of murder...
If that's true, then the villain in the shadows isn't some masked freak, but the
Codex Nocturnum itself.
But...
can it be true? Everything I've theorized until now rested on the assumption that the serial killer -and therefore the mastermind- was the Black Scribe. This case might have been flipped on its head...what a plot twist!